"My book is completely unique. There's nothing else like it on the market."
I hear this approximately three times a week. Usually from authors who've written another small-town romance where the heroine opens a bakery and falls in love with a grumpy contractor. Or another thriller where a detective with a tragic past hunts a serial killer.
"But my protagonist is different! She has trust issues from her childhood! And the love interest has a secret!"
Yes. Just like the other 47,000 small-town romances published this year.
Here's the paradox that breaks authors' brains: your book is absolutely unique. It's also exactly like everything else ever written. Both of these things are true simultaneously.
Understanding this paradox is the difference between authors who succeed and authors who spend years wondering why nobody's buying their "completely original" work.
Yes, Your Book Is Unique (In Ways That Don't Matter Much)
Your book is unique because:
You wrote it. Nobody else has your exact combination of life experiences, perspectives, obsessions, and neuroses. Your voice—the way you string sentences together, the details you notice, the metaphors that occur to you—is distinctly yours.
Your specific combination of story elements has never existed before. Sure, "enemies to lovers" has been done a million times. But not with your specific characters in your specific setting dealing with your specific conflicts.
You made ten thousand tiny creative decisions that nobody else would make the same way. Which scene to open with. What your protagonist eats for breakfast. Whether to describe the sunset or skip it. How your characters speak. What makes them laugh.
All of this makes your book genuinely unique.
It also doesn't matter as much as you think it does.
No, Your Book Isn't Special (In Ways That Matter A Lot)
Your book is exactly like everything else because:
It follows the same fundamental story structures humans have been using for thousands of years. Character wants something. Obstacles prevent them from getting it. They struggle. They change. They succeed or fail. That's every story ever told.
It uses tropes and conventions that readers expect from your genre. Romance needs romantic tension and a satisfying resolution. Mystery needs clues and revelation. Thriller needs escalating stakes. You're not reinventing these wheels. You're using the same wheels everyone else uses.
It competes with hundreds of thousands of other books for reader attention. Your unique voice and fresh take on familiar elements? So does everyone else. The marketplace is glutted with unique books.
Readers don't want something completely different. They want something familiar delivered in a way that feels fresh. Big difference.
The Paradox: Your book is unique in execution but universal in structure. It's distinctive in voice but conventional in purpose. It's one-of-a-kind in specifics but fundamentally the same as every other book in its category.
The "I'm Not Like Other Authors" Delusion
This is where authors get themselves in trouble.
"I don't need to study craft because my story is so unique it transcends traditional structure."
"I don't need to follow genre conventions because my book is breaking new ground."
"I don't need to worry about market positioning because my book will find its own audience."
No. No. And no.
Thinking you're special exempts you from nothing. Not from learning craft. Not from understanding your genre. Not from producing professional-quality work. Not from competing in a saturated marketplace.
Every author thinks their work is special. Most of them are wrong—not because their work isn't unique, but because uniqueness alone doesn't make a book good or sellable.
The authors who succeed understand this. They master the fundamentals first. They study structure and craft. They understand genre expectations. They learn the business of publishing.
Then—and only then—they apply their unique voice and perspective to create something that's both familiar and fresh.
Uniqueness built on ignorance is just incompetence wearing a disguise.
Why Genre Conventions Exist (And Why You Ignore Them At Your Peril)
Genre conventions aren't arbitrary rules designed to stifle creativity. They're proven patterns that readers in those genres expect and enjoy.
Romance readers want happy endings. Not because they're simple-minded, but because they're reading romance specifically for the emotional payoff of seeing characters find love. If you write a "romance" where the couple breaks up at the end, you haven't written a revolutionary romance. You've written a different genre and mislabeled it.
Mystery readers want the crime solved. Thriller readers want escalating stakes. Horror readers want to be scared. Fantasy readers want immersive world-building.
These aren't constraints. They're the foundation that allows you to build something interesting.
"But what about [famous author] who broke all the rules?"
They mastered the rules first. They understood exactly what they were breaking and why. They had enough skill to make it work despite—or because of—the rule-breaking.
You, with your first novel, are not that author. Not yet.
Learn the conventions. Understand why they exist. Master them. Then you can strategically bend or break them in ways that enhance your story rather than confusing your readers.
The Difference Between Voice and Gimmick
Authors often confuse having a unique voice with having a gimmick.
Voice is the authentic way you tell stories. It's the rhythm of your sentences. The details you notice. The metaphors that come naturally. The way you balance description, dialogue, and action. It develops over time and can't be faked.
Gimmick is writing your entire novel in second person present tense to be "different." Or structuring your thriller backwards because nobody's done that before. Or naming all your characters after vegetables because it's quirky.
Voice makes your work distinctive while still delivering what readers want. Gimmick makes your work weird for the sake of being weird.
Readers notice voice. It's why they prefer certain authors even when multiple authors write in the same genre. They connect with how that author tells stories.
Readers tolerate gimmicks only if the underlying story is strong enough to overcome the distraction. Usually, it isn't.
Your unique voice is valuable. Your clever gimmicks are usually self-indulgent.
Why "There's Nothing Else Like It" Is A Marketing Problem
Authors think "completely unique" is a selling point. It's actually a problem.
Readers don't browse looking for books unlike anything they've ever read. They browse looking for more books like the ones they already loved.
"If you liked Bridgerton, you'll love this" sells books. "There's nothing else like this on the market" makes readers nervous.
Why? Because readers want to know what they're getting. Genre signals, tropes, and comparisons tell them "this book will scratch a specific itch you have." Claiming to be completely unique tells them nothing useful.
Successful books aren't the ones with no comparison titles. They're the ones that fit clearly into existing categories while offering something fresh within those boundaries.
"A cozy mystery with a protagonist who's a retired assassin" works because readers know what "cozy mystery" means and the "retired assassin" twist makes it interesting.
"A completely unique story that defies genre classification" sounds like the author doesn't understand their own book.
The Myth of the Wholly Original Story
Here's a secret: there are no wholly original stories.
Every plot has been done. Every character type exists somewhere. Every twist has been twisted before. Every theme has been explored.
This isn't depressing. It's liberating.
You're not trying to invent something never seen before. You're trying to take universal elements and combine them in a way that feels fresh and emotionally resonant.
Romeo and Juliet isn't original—it's a forbidden love story that had been told a thousand times before Shakespeare. What made it work was the execution. The language. The emotional intensity. The specific details.
Harry Potter isn't original—it's a chosen one story at a magic school, combining elements from dozens of previous books. What made it work was Rowling's world-building, character development, and the specific way she told that familiar story.
Stop trying to write something nobody's ever seen before. Start trying to write something that makes familiar elements feel new through your unique execution.
How Uniqueness Actually Emerges
Your authentic uniqueness doesn't come from trying to be different. It comes from:
Writing what you're genuinely passionate about. Your enthusiasm bleeds into the work. Readers feel it.
Drawing from your specific life experience and perspective. Your background, your obsessions, your way of seeing the world—these naturally make your work distinctive.
Making ten thousand small creative choices that add up. Each scene structured your way. Each character speaking in their distinct voice. Each detail chosen for its emotional resonance.
Developing your craft until your natural voice emerges clearly. Beginners sound like everyone else because they're still learning. Advanced writers sound like themselves because they've mastered the fundamentals enough that their voice comes through.
Caring deeply about your story and characters. Books written as calculated market plays feel hollow. Books written because the author had to tell this specific story feel alive.
None of this requires you to reject genre conventions, ignore market realities, or convince yourself you're revolutionizing literature.
It just requires you to write honestly and well.
The Balance: Familiar Enough, Fresh Enough
Successful books hit a sweet spot:
Familiar enough that readers recognize what kind of book it is and know whether they're interested. They see it's a thriller or a romance or a fantasy. They understand the basic promise.
Fresh enough that it doesn't feel like a copy of something they've already read. The voice is distinctive. The specific execution offers something new. The combination of elements creates something that feels both comfortable and surprising.
Too familiar? Generic and forgettable. Competent but boring. Readers finish it and immediately forget they read it.
Too fresh? Confusing and off-putting. Readers don't know what they're getting. They can't connect it to anything they already like. It doesn't scratch any itch they recognize having.
The balance is different for every genre and every book. But the principle holds: you want readers to feel like they're getting what they came for while also discovering something they didn't expect.
The Test: Can you describe your book in one sentence that includes both genre identification and a unique hook? If not, you're either too generic or too weird.
Why Comparison Titles Matter
When agents, publishers, and readers ask for comparison titles, they're not asking you to prove your book is different from everything else.
They're asking you to help them understand where your book fits and what makes it interesting within that category.
"It's Bridgerton meets The Hunger Games" immediately tells readers: historical romance with high stakes and action. They know if they're interested.
"It's like The Martian but literary fiction" tells readers: survival story with humor and problem-solving, but written with more emphasis on character interiority and prose style.
Authors who can't or won't provide comparison titles are either:
So unfamiliar with their genre they don't know what else exists. (Problem.)
So convinced of their uniqueness they refuse to acknowledge any similarities. (Bigger problem.)
Writing something genuinely difficult to categorize. (Occasionally legitimate, usually problematic for finding readers.)
Know what your book is similar to. Then articulate what makes it different. That's positioning. That's how books get sold.
The Bottom Line
Your book is unique. So is everyone else's.
Uniqueness is necessary but not sufficient. You also need craft, structure, understanding of your genre, professional execution, and effective positioning.
Stop using "my book is unique" as an excuse to ignore fundamentals. Stop thinking being different exempts you from learning how stories work. Stop believing your special snowflake status will magically attract readers.
Master the craft. Understand your genre. Learn the business. Then apply your unique voice and perspective to create work that's both familiar enough to find its audience and distinctive enough to stand out.
That's how books succeed. Not through revolutionary uniqueness, but through skilled execution of universal elements delivered with authentic voice.
You're unique. Congratulations. So is everyone.
Now get back to work and write something good.
Back To Cedar Savage Press Index Page