Writers frequently send me sample chapters of their books, telling me, "I have to go with a traditional publisher because I can't afford to self-publish."
Let me say this clearly: if you genuinely cannot afford the upfront costs of hiring an editor, cover designer, formatter, and marketing help, then traditional publishing is absolutely the right choice for you. There's no shame in that. Traditional publishers cover those costs in exchange for a larger share of your royalties. That's a legitimate business model, and for many authors—especially debut authors—it's the smart play.
But here's what I need you to understand: your book is going to cost money either way.
The question isn't whether you'll pay. The question is when and how.
The Money Talk Nobody Wants to Have
With traditional publishing, the publisher pays thousands of dollars upfront for editing, design, marketing, and distribution. You don't write a check, but you pay for it through smaller royalty percentages and the possibility that your advance may be all you ever see if the book doesn't earn out.
With self-publishing, you write the checks yourself—potentially thousands of dollars before you see a single sale. But you keep a much larger percentage of every dollar your book earns.
Neither option is free. Both are business decisions. And both require you to produce a professional-quality product or you're wasting everyone's time and money.
Why I'm Writing This
Here's my primary frustration: ninety percent of the writers who contact me send material that is amateurish and poorly written, with no construction or flow. They write what they see in their heads, assuming the reader can follow along—even though the reader isn't in the writer's head and cannot possibly track the train of thought or divine the writer's intention.
And almost without exception, they tell me some version of: "My best friend says it's great. My mom loved it. My Sunday school class couldn't put it down. So I know it's ready to publish."
No. It's not.
I don't care how much your mother loves your book. I don't care if your best friend cried at the ending. I don't care if your entire book club stayed up all night reading it. Without professional editing, your book is not ready. It might be good. It might even have the bones of something great. But without spit and polish from someone who does this for a living, it's not going to compete with the professionally edited books readers can choose instead.
This is true whether you're submitting to Random House or uploading to Amazon.
The Truth About First Drafts
Every single one of the best books you've ever read—the ones you'd recommend without hesitation—started out as terrible first drafts. Sloppy. Disjointed. No flow. Repetitive. Rough.
What transforms that mess into something worth reading? A team of professionals working to take it from "inventor's vision" to "flying off the shelves."
And yes, I said inventor. Because you are not just a writer. You are an inventor, and your book is your product.
Think of it this way: you invent a better mousetrap. And by "better mousetrap," I mean a life-altering, game-changing thing so incredible that you can't stop yourself from talking about it and hoping all your friends will try it and love it as much as you do.
It could be a mousetrap. It could be dishwashing detergent. It could be a particular vacuum cleaner.
Or it could be a book.
No product makes it to market without a team—however small or large—to take it from "inventor's vision" to "ready to ship." No matter how inventive, frugal, handy, or clever you are, you will not possess all the skills, knowledge, and experience needed to turn your idea into something consumers will pay for.
It works exactly the same way with a book.
What It Actually Takes to Publish a Book
Very few writers—and by very few, I mean essentially zero, except for a handful of rare individuals—possess every skill needed to take their book idea from Page One to published product. To do so, an individual must be able to:
Craft a compelling story. Write the story with clean, engaging prose. Rewrite the story (multiple times). Self-edit with enough objectivity to see the story's flaws. Choose and work with a professional editor. Rewrite again based on editorial feedback. Send the manuscript back for another editorial pass. Find and work with a proofreader. Hunt down every remaining error and weakness. Choose a cover designer who understands genre and marketing. Choose a formatter who can make the interior look professional. Write compelling back cover copy and book descriptions. Navigate ISBN numbers, distribution channels, and metadata. Understand keywords, categories, and discoverability. Develop and execute a marketing strategy.
When you sign with a traditional publisher, their staff handles all of this. When you self-publish, you either do it yourself (badly) or you hire professionals to do it (expensively).
Why Every Book Needs Editing—Yes, Even Yours
All books need editing. Period. It doesn't matter how skilled the author is or how perfect her beta readers insist it is.
Here's why: writers are too close to their own work. You know what you meant to say. You know the backstory you didn't include. You know why that character made that decision. Your reader doesn't. You need fresh eyes—professional eyes—to tell you where you've lost clarity, where the pacing drags, where you've repeated yourself, where you've accidentally changed your protagonist's eye color, and where you've used "just" forty-seven times in three chapters.
Editors catch the plot holes you didn't see because you know how it ends. They identify the scenes that don't move the story forward. They flag the dialogue that sounds stilted or the description that goes on too long. They find the inconsistencies, the logical gaps, the places where you made a leap that works in your head but not on the page.
Even the best writers cannot effectively edit their own work. Stephen King has an editor. Nora Roberts has an editor. Every author published by a traditional house has multiple editors—developmental, line, copy, and proof. This isn't because these authors can't write. It's because editing your own work is like performing surgery on yourself. Theoretically possible. Practically inadvisable.
Your mother loves you. Your best friend wants to be supportive. Your Sunday school class doesn't want to hurt your feelings. None of them are qualified to edit your book. They can be beta readers—valuable ones, even—but they cannot replace a professional editor who has spent years learning how to identify and fix the problems that tank a book's chances.
The Real Costs of Self-Publishing
I'm currently paying an editor $1,000 to edit a book for me. And I can afford that, but a lot of people can't, and I get it—especially since most editors charge more than that for a moderately-sized manuscript.
But that's just the editor. Self-publishing also requires:
A developmental editor ($1,500–$3,000 or more) to assess whether your story structure works, whether your characters are compelling, whether your pacing keeps readers engaged, and whether the whole thing hangs together.
A copyeditor ($1,000–$2,000) to fix grammar, improve clarity, catch inconsistencies, and polish your prose sentence by sentence.
A proofreader ($500–$1,000) to catch the typos and formatting errors that survive previous editing rounds.
A cover designer ($500–$2,000) who understands genre conventions and can create something that looks professional and signals to your target readers, "This is the kind of book you like."
A formatter ($200–$500) to ensure your book's interior looks clean and professional in both print and digital formats.
Marketing and promotion ($???—anywhere from a few hundred dollars to tens of thousands) including website hosting, ads, newsletter services, and promotional materials.
We're talking $4,000 to $10,000 or more before you sell a single copy. Maybe you can shave costs by learning to format yourself or by finding newer professionals willing to work for less. But you cannot skip these steps entirely and expect professional results.
If you don't have $4,000 to $10,000 sitting around—and most people don't—then traditional publishing is your answer. The publisher fronts those costs. Yes, you'll give up a larger share of royalties. Yes, you might never earn out your advance. But you also won't be $8,000 in the hole if your book doesn't sell.
The Business of Books
Gone are the days of sending off a manuscript and having Worldwide Publishers lose their mind over your book, cut you a $500,000 advance, and book a worldwide tour. That scenario was always rare, and for debut authors today, it's virtually extinct.
The best way to set yourself up to succeed at writing and publishing is to stop thinking of yourself as just a writer and start thinking of yourself as a small business owner who has invented a product.
Because that's what you are.
Your book is a product. You are the inventor. Whether you self-publish or go traditional, you are entering into a business arrangement. The economics are different, but both require you to deliver a professional-quality product to have any chance of success.
If you self-publish, you are the CEO of a small business. You make all the decisions, you manage the budget, you hire the contractors, and you keep the lion's share of the profits—if there are any.
If you traditionally publish, you are licensing your invention to a manufacturer who will refine it, package it, and distribute it in exchange for a percentage of sales. You give up control and a larger share of revenue, but you also give up the financial risk.
The Choice Is Yours
So here are your options:
Option 1: Traditional Publishing
Submit to agents and publishers. If they accept your book, they cover all production costs. You get an advance (usually modest for debut authors) and royalties if your book earns out. This is the right choice if you cannot afford upfront costs, want professional support, or prefer to focus on writing while someone else handles production and distribution.
Option 2: Self-Publishing Done Right
Save money until you can afford to hire editors, designers, formatters, and marketing help. Invest $4,000–$10,000 (or more) to produce a book that looks and reads as professionally as anything from a traditional publisher. Keep 70% of your royalties instead of 10–15%. This is the right choice if you have the capital, want creative control, and are willing to learn the business side of publishing.
Option 3: Self-Publishing on the Cheap
Skip the professionals, use a template cover, upload an unedited manuscript, and hope for the best. This costs almost nothing upfront and will almost certainly earn you almost nothing in return. Readers will spot the amateur quality immediately, leave mediocre reviews (if they review it at all), and move on. This is the right choice if... actually, this is never the right choice. Don't do this.
One More Thing: AI Is Not the Answer
If you're thinking about using AI to generate your book—writing it Friday and uploading it Monday—stop.
AI cannot write a compelling book. It can string words together. It can mimic patterns. But it cannot craft a story that resonates emotionally, builds authentic characters, or creates the narrative tension that keeps readers turning pages at two in the morning.
More importantly, flooding the market with AI-generated content tanks your reputation as an author before you've even built one. Readers aren't stupid. They can tell when they're reading something soulless and generic. And they remember the authors who tried to pass off shoddy work as the real thing.
The Bottom Line
Your book is going to cost money. You will pay for professional editing, design, and marketing one way or another—either upfront with self-publishing or through smaller royalties with traditional publishing.
What you cannot do—or rather, what you can do but absolutely should not do—is upload a poorly written, unedited, badly formatted book with an amateur cover and expect anything other than disappointing results.
I don't want to be harsh about this, but I'm going to be honest: I have the same conversation with every new author, and the ones who succeed are the ones who understand that publishing is a business. Treat your book like a product. Invest in making it the best product possible. Understand the economics of your chosen publishing path. And for the love of everything literary, hire a professional editor.
Your book deserves that. More importantly, you deserve that.
Back to Articles