Let me tell you about the traditional agent query system: it's a lottery designed to crush your soul while promising you the golden ticket.
Query 50 agents. Get 48 form rejections, one "not right for my list," and dead silence from the 50th. Revise your query letter based on advice from seventeen different blog posts that all contradict each other. Query 50 more agents. Repeat until you either give up or die.
And the writers who succeed? They'll tell you it's because they "perfected their craft" or "found the right agent for their voice." What they won't tell you is they sent 300 queries over three years, got lucky with timing, or had a connection they're too polite to mention.
The system is broken. Not "could use some improvement" broken. Structurally, fundamentally, burn-it-down-and-start-over broken.
Why The Query System Doesn't Work Anymore
The math is impossible. A working literary agent receives 50 to 200 queries per week. That's 2,600 to 10,400 queries per year. They might take on 2 to 5 new clients annually. Your odds? Somewhere between 0.02% and 0.2%. You have better odds playing blackjack.
Nobody reads past the first paragraph. Agents will tell you they read every query. They're lying or delusional. When you're looking at 50 queries before lunch, you're skimming. One sentence grabs you or it doesn't. The quality of your book? Irrelevant if your query doesn't hook them in ten seconds.
The sample pages don't matter if your query is bland. You attached your first chapter like they asked. The one you revised forty times. The one your critique group called "gripping." Nobody's reading it because your query letter sounded like every other query letter they saw that morning.
Agents want what's already selling. They say they want fresh voices and original stories. What they actually want is "X meets Y"—something close enough to a current bestseller that they can pitch it easily but different enough to not be a knockoff. That's not a criticism. That's economics. Publishers buy what they think they can sell, and agents rep what they think publishers will buy.
Timing is everything and you can't control it. Your query about a pandemic novel hits an agent's inbox in March 2020? Perfect timing. April 2021? Everyone's sick of pandemic stories. You have no way to know what agents are tired of seeing or desperate to find. You're throwing darts blindfolded.
The process takes forever. Query, wait 6-8 weeks for a response (or forever if they don't respond to rejections). Get rejected. Revise query. Research new agents. Query again. Wait another 6-8 weeks. You can burn through two years of your life querying and have nothing to show for it except a growing collection of form rejections.
But I Thought You HAD To Have An Agent?
You were lied to.
Here's what agents actually do: they pitch your manuscript to publishers (mostly the Big Five and their imprints), negotiate your contract, handle subsidiary rights, and take 15% of everything your book earns.
That's it. That's the job.
You need an agent if:
• You want to publish with a traditional Big Five publisher
• You need help negotiating a complex contract
• You want someone to handle foreign rights, film rights, etc.
• You value the legitimacy and validation of traditional publishing
You don't need an agent if:
• You're willing to publish independently
• You can handle your own marketing anyway (because traditional publishers sure aren't doing it for debut authors)
• You want creative control over your book
• You want to actually earn money from your writing in the next five years
What Traditional Publishing Actually Looks Like Now
Let's say you win the lottery. You get an agent. They sell your book. Here's what happens:
The advance. For debut authors, expect $5,000 to $15,000. Maybe $25,000 if you're lucky. That's split into three or four payments over 18+ months. Your agent takes 15%. After taxes, you're looking at maybe $7,000 in your pocket for a year and a half of work.
The timeline. From agent signing to book on shelves? 2-3 years minimum. You'll spend most of that time waiting. Waiting for your agent to pitch it. Waiting for publishers to respond. Waiting for contract negotiations. Waiting for editorial rounds. Waiting for cover design. Waiting for the publication date they picked that's 18 months away because that's how publishing scheduling works.
The marketing. Your publisher will do the bare minimum unless you're a proven bestseller or celebrity. You're getting a basic cover, a listing in their catalog, and maybe—maybe—a small social media push. Everything else? That's on you. You'll be doing your own marketing, building your own platform, and driving your own sales while earning 10-15% royalties instead of the 70% you'd get self-publishing.
The control. You don't pick your cover. You don't pick your title (if they hate it). You don't control pricing. You don't decide when it goes on sale. You signed a contract that gave the publisher control over nearly everything about your book's publication.
Your Actual Options
Stop thinking there's only one way to publish. There isn't. Here are your real choices:
Option 1: Keep Querying (If You Must)
Some of you won't be happy unless you've exhausted the traditional route. Fine. But do it smart:
• Set a limit. 100 queries, one year, then you move on. Don't spend five years of your life chasing form rejections.
• Query in batches. Send 10, see what feedback you get, revise if needed, send 10 more.
• Write the next book while you wait. Don't put your entire writing career on hold waiting for agents to respond.
• Consider small presses that don't require agents. They're not Big Five prestigious, but they're legitimate publishers who might actually read your manuscript.
Option 2: Independent Publishing Done Right
This is where most writers should be looking if they're serious about building a career.
Yes, it costs money upfront. Yes, you need to learn the business side. Yes, you're responsible for everything.
But you keep 70% of your royalties, you control everything about your book, you can publish on your timeline, and you can actually make a living if you're willing to write multiple books and learn how to reach readers.
What it actually takes:
• $4,000-$10,000 for professional editing, cover design, and formatting
• Time to learn the basics of Amazon KDP, IngramSpark, or other platforms
• Willingness to handle your own marketing (which you'd be doing anyway with traditional publishing)
• Ability to write multiple books because one-book authors rarely succeed in any publishing model
Option 3: Hybrid Approach
Publish independently while still querying agents. You can do both.
Indie publish your first book. If it sells well, you've got leverage. Agents are a lot more interested in authors who've proven they can move books. Some debut indie authors land traditional deals for their second or third book based on their self-publishing success.
You're not burning bridges. You're building a career while keeping your options open.
The Real Question You Should Be Asking
Stop asking "How do I get an agent?"
Start asking "How do I get my book into readers' hands and build a sustainable writing career?"
Because that's the actual goal, isn't it? You didn't write this book so it could collect rejections. You wrote it because you have something to say and you want people to read it.
The agent query system is one possible path to that goal. It's not the only path. It's not even the best path for most writers anymore. It's just the path that's been romanticized and sold to you as "the dream."
The dream is having readers. The dream is writing more books. The dream is building a career where you can keep doing this thing you love.
You can chase that dream through the query trenches if you want. But you can also walk around them and get where you're going a lot faster.
What To Do Right Now
Make a decision. Really make one.
If you're committed to traditional publishing: Set your limits. Query smart. Write the next book. Don't wait around for permission to call yourself a writer.
If you're considering indie publishing: Stop letting fear and stigma hold you back. Indie publishing isn't the fallback anymore—it's a legitimate first choice that gives you control and potentially better earnings.
If you're not sure: Do both. Publish indie while you query. The worst that happens? Your book is out in the world instead of sitting in a drawer collecting digital dust.
The agent query system is broken, but your writing career doesn't have to be. Stop waiting for someone to give you permission. Take a different path.
Your book deserves to find readers. One way or another, make that happen.
Back to Articles